In 2019, the Offender Database recorded that Shannon Soutter, 23, avoided a prison sentence despite admitting to a series of violent attacks that left a six-month-old girl with permanent brain damage. On appearing at the High Court in Glasgow, the defendant, of Blairgowrie, Perthshire, was handed a community payback order. It was reported that the assaults took place over a two-month period in 2018 at a property in Arbroath, Angus, resulting in the infant suffering a fractured skull, broken ribs, and a fractured ankle.
The investigation established the catastrophic nature of the injuries inflicted by Soutter. Police Scotland reported that the child was left with severe brain damage and potential permanent blindness, with medical professionals describing her long-term prognosis as poor. The prosecution reported that Soutter pleaded guilty to assaulting the girl to her severe injury, permanent impairment, and to the danger of her life, admitting that her actions had fundamentally altered the infant’s quality of existence.
Judicial Findings and Investigative Detail
The court reported that Soutter was struggling with a history of depression and personal issues at the time of the offending. The High Court in Glasgow heard that Soutter suffered from vouched mental health difficulties, which the judge cited as a reason for leniency. The investigation established that the baby’s father provided a moving victim impact statement, detailing the immense stress and responsibility of providing lifelong care for a child with such complex needs.
Lord Turnbull stated that the circumstances were unusual enough to warrant a degree of mercy, suggesting that Soutter’s own daily self-punishment was a significant factor. For her actions in Arbroath, Soutter was ordered to carry out 300 hours of unpaid work as part of a three-year community payback order. The judge noted that while the public duty did not require incarceration, Soutter must undergo mental health treatment and is strictly prohibited from having any unsupervised contact with children.
Status and Statutory Requirements
For the crimes reported in Scotland, the status of Shannon Soutter is as follows:
- Sentence: 3-year Community Payback Order (Sentenced 2019).
- Unpaid Work: 300 hours.
- Supervision: Mandatory mental health treatment and child contact restrictions.
- Judicial Oversight: Sentenced at the High Court in Glasgow following a Police Scotland investigation.
- Criminal Record: Assault to severe injury, permanent impairment, and danger of life.
- Origin: Blairgowrie, Perthshire (Offences in Arbroath, Angus).
Monitoring and Public Protection
Soutter is managed under the supervision of local authority criminal justice social work services in Perthshire. Due to the nature of her conduct in Angus, which involved life-threatening violence against a defenceless infant, her management includes a strict prohibition on unsupervised access to underage children. Authorities state that her compliance with mental health treatment is a mandatory requirement of her order, intended to address the underlying issues that led to the severe and permanent damage of the victim.
As a convicted violent offender, Soutter’s details remain a permanent part of the national record. Authorities state that the decision to grant mercy in Glasgow was based on her specific mental health profile, but her status as a risk to minors remains a priority for safeguarding teams. Any future attempt to work with children or a failure to attend mandated treatment in Blairgowrie will result in a breach of her order and an immediate return to court for a potential custodial sentence.
If you or anyone you know has been affected by the individuals highlighted on this website, please report them to the Police on 101 (999 in an emergency) or visit their online resources for further details on reporting a crime. You can also report to Crimestoppers if you wish to remain completely anonymous. There is help available on our support links page.